Peter Gutmann and Stephan Neuhaus have a new paper”, I think it’s new, even though it has a March 2025 date”, that makes the argument that we shouldn’t trust any of the quantum factorization benchmarks, because everyone has been cooking the books:
Similarly, quantum factorisation is performed using sleight-of-hand numbers that have been selected to make them very easy to factorise using a physics experiment and, by extension, a VIC-20, an abacus, and a dog. A standard technique is to ensure that the factors differ by only a few bits that can then be found using a simple search-based approach that has nothing to do with factorisation”¦. Note that such a value would never be encountered in the real world since the RSA key generation process typically requires that -p-q- > 100 or more bits [9]. As one analysis puts it, “Instead of waiting for the hardware to improve by yet further orders of magnitude, researchers began inventing better and better tricks for factoring numbers by exploiting their hidden structure” [10]…
First seen on securityboulevard.com
Jump to article: securityboulevard.com/2025/07/cheating-on-quantum-computing-benchmarks/
